UN’s Inconsistent Stance on Terror Sparks Debate

by / ⠀Blog / October 18, 2023
Hamas and Hezbollah

The United Nations (UN) has not classified Hamas as a terrorist organization or enforced any sanctions against it, even though the group has been involved in several attacks and is acknowledged as a terrorist organization by multiple countries. Richard Goldberg, a senior advisor at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, points out that while the UN Security Council has chosen to impose sanctions and classify organizations such as al Qaeda, the Taliban, and ISIS, it has not taken similar steps against Iran’s network of terror groups, which includes Hamas and Hezbollah.

This disparity in classification has raised concerns and debates regarding the UN’s approach to addressing terrorism and the measures taken against various extremist groups. Critics argue that this lack of consistency could potentially undermine the effectiveness of the UN’s counterterrorism efforts and send mixed signals to the international community concerning the organization’s stance on terrorism.

Sanctions on ISIS and al Qaeda

Sanctions have been imposed on ISIS and al Qaeda through resolutions adopted in 1999, 2011, and 2015. However, comparable actions have not been taken against Hamas and Hezbollah. Israel’s ongoing struggles with these organizations persist, as seen in a recent unexpected attack by Hamas that claimed the lives of over 1,300 Israelis. This disparity in the approach towards these terrorist groups has raised questions among the international community. Calls for unified and stringent measures against all such organizations, including Hamas and Hezbollah, have increasingly gained momentum in order to ensure global security and prevent further loss of innocent lives.

How the UN Treats Hamas and Hezbollah

Goldberg, who previously served as the director for counteracting weapons of mass destruction at the White House National Security Council, criticized the UN’s approach to these organizations, stating that the UN regards them as “legitimate political movements,” and therefore does not hesitate to cooperate with them. Both the United States and Israel have spoken out against the UN, particularly the Security Council, for its alleged anti-Israel bias. In a joint statement, the US and Israel have called for a more stringent stance against terrorist organizations in order to ensure global security and maintain diplomatic integrity. They highlight the importance of addressing and combating the threats posed by these groups, rather than supporting them through recognition or cooperation.

See also  The Entrepreneurial Time Machine

Previous Attempts to Designate Hamas as a Terrorist Organization

In 2018, then-Ambassador Nikki Haley put forward a resolution during the Trump administration to designate Hamas as a terrorist organization, but it only garnered one supporting vote, that of the U.S. An effort to have the UN General Assembly denounce Hamas also proved fruitless. Since then, efforts to designate Hamas as a terrorist organization have faced numerous obstacles within the international community. Diverse perspectives on Hamas’ role in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict have contributed to the lack of consensus in these attempts.

Recent U.S. Call for Denouncement of Hamas

Recently, the U.S. called on the Council to denounce “these atrocious terrorist attacks carried out by Hamas,” but no immediate action has been taken. This lack of response has caused immense frustration among U.S. officials and prompted further discussions on the importance of addressing terrorism. In the meantime, the international community remains divided on the most effective approach towards dealing with terrorist organizations like Hamas.

Israeli Ambassador’s Response

Israeli Ambassador Gilad Erdan expressed his displeasure with the UN’s reaction to the attack, suggesting that the organization should concentrate on “recovering the hostages, denouncing Hamas, and supporting Israel’s right to defend itself.” In a statement, Erdan also emphasized the importance of recognizing the role of terrorist organizations in destabilizing the region and urged the UN to adopt a firm stance against such groups. He further added that Israel expects the international community to join forces in condemning these actions and providing necessary aid to ensure the safety of its citizens.

See also  How to Deal With Office Politics

The disparity in classification and lack of sanctions against Hamas and Hezbollah have raised concerns regarding the UN’s approach to addressing terrorism and the measures taken against various extremist groups. Critics argue that this inconsistency could potentially undermine the effectiveness of the UN’s counterterrorism efforts and send mixed signals to the international community concerning the organization’s stance on terrorism. It is evident that the international community remains divided on the most effective approach towards dealing with terrorist organizations like Hamas, and unified efforts in combating these threats are of utmost importance in ensuring global security and preventing further loss of innocent lives.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Why hasn’t the United Nations classified Hamas as a terrorist organization?

The UN has not classified Hamas as a terrorist organization or enforced sanctions against it because they regard them as “legitimate political movements.” This is in contrast to other groups like al Qaeda, the Taliban, and ISIS, which have been sanctioned and classified as terrorist organizations by the UN Security Council.

What is the criticism against the UN’s approach to Hamas and Hezbollah?

Critics argue that the disparity in classification and lack of sanctions against Hamas and Hezbollah could potentially undermine the effectiveness of the UN’s counterterrorism efforts and send mixed signals to the international community regarding the organization’s stance on terrorism.

What measures have been taken against ISIS and al Qaeda by the UN?

Sanctions have been imposed on ISIS and al Qaeda through resolutions adopted in 1999, 2011, and 2015. These actions, however, have not been taken against Hamas and Hezbollah, causing concerns and debates among the international community.

See also  The Challenges Facing Our Generation: A Response To An Open Letter to Under30CEO

How has the United States and Israel responded to the UN’s approach to Hamas and Hezbollah?

Both the United States and Israel have criticized the UN, particularly the Security Council, for its alleged anti-Israel bias. They have called for a more stringent stance against terrorist organizations to ensure global security and maintain diplomatic integrity.

What has been done to designate Hamas as a terrorist organization within the UN?

In 2018, then-Ambassador Nikki Haley put forward a resolution to designate Hamas as a terrorist organization, but it only garnered one supporting vote from the U.S. Additionally, an effort to have the UN General Assembly denounce Hamas proved fruitless.

What is the current status of efforts towards denouncing Hamas?

Recently, the U.S. called on the Council to denounce “these atrocious terrorist attacks carried out by Hamas,” but no immediate action has been taken. The international community remains divided on the most effective approach towards dealing with terrorist organizations like Hamas.

First Reported on: foxnews.com
Featured Image Credit: Photo by Mathias Reding; Pexels; Thank you!

About The Author

Kimberly Zhang

Editor in Chief of Under30CEO. I have a passion for helping educate the next generation of leaders.

x

Get Funded Faster!

Proven Pitch Deck

Signup for our newsletter to get access to our proven pitch deck template.